John B. MacDonald (1944-2026)

 

 

We learned that John MacDonald died on October 18, 2026.  Click here for his obituary.

 

About John:

 

John followed his father to Princeton, after graduating from Monroe-Woodbury High School, in Central Valley, New York.

 

At Princeton, he majored in history, belonged to Charter Club, played in the marching band, and volunteered with the Trenton Tutorial Project. Senior year, he roomed with Roger Evans and Guy Woelk in 1939 Hall.

 

John played saxophone in a campus rock band called the Hustlers, with Carl Jacobs on bass and Jeff Wood on guitar. The band played on campus and at colleges throughout the Northeast. One highlight was playing backup for The Exciters, of “Tell Him” fame.

 

After Princeton, John earned a master’s degree in education from Oberlin College and a doctorate in education from Columbia University’s Teachers College.

 

He dedicated his career to education as a teacher at James I. O’Neill High School, in Highland Falls, New York. He also served as a member of the Monroe-Woodbury School Board, president of the Monroe Tennis Club, and member of the Souza Scholarship Committee.

 

In addition to playing classical guitar, he was a gardener, woodworker, chef, and athlete. 

 

John is survived by his wife, Ronnee; children, Joshua, Melinda Gormley, and Sarah MacDonald; and five grandchildren. The Class sends its condolences to all of them.

 

Entry in our 50th Reunion Book (Supplement):

 

8 Forge Rd., Monroe, NY 10950-3908; 845-782-0453;

Spouse: Ronnee Ellen MacDonald

Community service: Member, Monroe-Woodbury

Board of Education, 2011-14

Activities: tennis, classical guitar, gardening, reading, travel

 

Thinking back to my days at Princeton, I recall that my social life revolved around my roommates and Charter Club. I remember professors, like Eric Goldman, James Billington, and Joseph Strayer, who stimulated my interest in history. Taking part in the Trenton Tutorial program encouraged my interest in teaching. Count Basie, Duke Ellington, Charles Lloyd, and Bob Dylan provided great performances for me to hear. However, one experience I had was quite different, mixing people of different classes and working on and off campus. 

 

I always considered myself lucky that in my first days at Princeton I was able to become the sax player in a good rock & roll band. The original group, known as the Hustlers, was made up of Jim Okie ’64 (drums), John Hartnett ’64 (guitar), and Peter Polatin ’64 (piano). Two other Class of ’66 members, Carl Jacobs on bass and Jeff Wood on guitar, also joined the group in that fall of 1962. The next year Tom Thomas ’67 became our lead singer, and when Jim, John, and Peter graduated, drummer Javier Johnson ’67 (later listed in the alumni directory as Javier White) became part of the group. Carl was our new leader.

 

On many weekends we played at eating clubs and other events on the campus. Often though, we traveled to play at Northeastern colleges and universities such as Yale, Amherst, and Mt. Holyoke. We even were paid to perform at a birthday party in Chicago and another on Park Avenue in New York City. It was a good time to play music. We were paid well, given free food and drinks, and our audiences appreciated our ability to play favorite hits of groups like the Beatles, the Beach Boys, and the Rolling Stones, as well as many R&B standards.

 

Being in a music group had a number of other perks. Wearing our band jackets, we were usually allowed on our breaks to walk in and listen to the professional groups performing at other clubs and fraternities. I remember talking for awhile to King Curtis at Tiger Inn and at Yale to some of the members of Bo Diddley’s group. I also remember times when we practiced at Tiger Inn and would have one of the kitchen workers who had played with Jimmy Reed sit in with us. Occasionally, we also had chances to back up vocal groups, like the Exciters, at dances. 

 

After graduation, the Hustlers only played together one more time. Some of us continued to play in other groups. We still have the one recording we made, but we have never been able to find a photograph of our group. For me, playing in the band for those years was a great experience and satisfied most of my desire to go to wild parties. Later, I became interested in quieter things, like learning to play the classical guitar.

 

Entry on our Website:

 

After Princeton, I went to Oberlin College in Ohio to get my Masters Degree in Education. I did my practice teaching in Rocky River next to Cleveland. I taught senior electives in economics and sociology. Oberlin gave me a good start for teaching. It was different from Princeton, but I enjoyed it.

 

In February 1968, I was hired to teach history in Highland Falls, New York. (You might remember songs by Billy Joel “Summer Highland Falls” and “A New York State of Mind.”) The district is located on the west side of the Hudson River between the Bear Mountain bridge and West Point. The high school is made up of a mix of black and white students whose families are rooted in the town, the high school age students from West Point, and students who choose to come to Highland Falls from Garrison, a district across the river that has no high school of it’s own. I was amazed at how well the students got along.

 

Ronnee Weinstein, the love of my life, and I were married on October 17, 1976. She became a special education teacher while at Syracuse and went to Teachers College for her Masters. She became a teacher at Monroe-Woodbury, the school system I had graduated from. We had a house built in Monroe and have been living there 44 years. We have three children: Melinda, Joshua, and Sarah. Our four grandchildren Eoin, Aoife, Aine, and Aisling belong to Melinda and our Irishman Michael Gormley. They are only a few blocks from us.

 

Meanwhile, in Highland Falls, I taught world history to sophomores and electives, such as psychology and economics, to upper class students. I also coached cross country for a few years and tennis for most of the time I was there. In the early ’80’s, the district had a new superintendent who wanted to give teachers room to experiment to improve their teaching and for students to have chances to have some input too. For me it was a wake up call. As a result, a science teacher and myself spent a part of the day helping the changing needs of teachers, students and administrators. We added after school activities, such as mock trials, Odyssey of the Mind, and interscholastic quiz bowls. Some of our students wanted to go to the Soviet Union and so we took 30 students and a few parents to Moscow and Leningrad during that year’s spring break.

 

As the years went by, I became more interested in how schools developed their curriculums. The district gave sabbaticals to teachers and I was able to get one, so I applied for a doctoral program at Teachers College, Columbia University. I was accepted and began my drives into the city for classes. Teaching and taking courses makes for slow progress towards a degree, but I valued the experience. My dissertation was titled: State Curriculum Policies and Teachers’ Practice: The Experiences of Three New York State Social Studies Teachers. I had a terrific advisor, Linda Darling-Hammond.

 

I retired from Highland Falls in 2000, partly to finish my dissertation, partly because the state had an especially good retirement package, and partly to spend more time with the family. I finished my dissertation in 2003 and our three children found colleges to attend: Melinda to the University of Massachusetts; Sarah to Brandeis, and Joshua, after four years in the Air Force, to the University of Delaware. I was on the Board of Education for Monroe-Woodbury for three years.

 

We’re trying to get back to normal. Yesterday we had our second shot against the covid virus. For the last year, we have followed the best practices against the virus. Now that the weather is getting better, we will be able to walk outside and I’ll start to plant my garden. During the winter I play tennis indoors, but soon we’ll be playing on our outside Monroe clay courts. We like to travel at least three times a year. We have taken trips lately through Princeton, one on the Danube and the other to Costa Rica and Panama. They were great.

 

Nassau Herald:

 

 

 

Classmate Memories and Tributes:

 

Roger Evans:

 

Yes I knew John essentially my entire time at P-ton and he roomed with Guy Woelk and me in 1939 Hall senior year.  Soft spoken, but very witty with dry humor, he was a joy to be around.  I was jealous of his musical ability with his sax playing in bands.  A true gentleman I think he may have been our only classmate to have a career as a public high school teacher.

 

Carl Jacobs:

 

Really good sax player, really good guy. His father went to Princeton. We stayed in some touch. I was on the way to Woodstock with my wife and young baby when we heard it was a mess, so we turned around. John lived nearby and we went over there, ended up staying the night. I think the name of the New York town was Monroe. We also had some communication later about a band in which I was performing. John really knew the Hudson Valley music scene and I learned a lot from him about the music world. With The Hustlers we traveled all over the northeast performing. Very sorry to hear that he died.

 

Walter Thomas:

 

I actually roomed with John and Guy Woelk for a spell in 1940 dorm (since torn down), because I was a retread and came back in Spring semester. As I recall, there were just the three of us in a huge living space and we had Bloody Mary parties every Sunday which were quite the thing. The Bloody Marys were iced down in large polyurethane containers that we stole from Biology and were used to store cadavers. We had great music and of course one of the favorites was Roger Miller’s Chug-a-Lug. The record was 3 seconds for a 12 ounce can. We made runs to Phillie to buy Colt 45 malt liquor.

 

John loved music and loved the band. We played a lot of songs from a New Orleans record album called Home of the Blues which featured Aaron Neville, Ernie K. Doe and others and of course the all time favorite Ooh Poo Pah Doo by Jesse Hill.

 

One of John’s favorite songs was the Coasters’ I’m a Hog for You Baby, because he had a sax solo and could make the sax sound like it was farting!

 

He was mild mannered (but liked a good party) never said a bad word about anyone and was a good friend at Princeton.

 

 

If you have photos, information, or memories that you wish to share, please send them to the '66 Memorial Team (66_MemorialTeam@googlegroups.com). We will add them to this page.